Vụ án thảm sát làng Đặng Đề, huyện Bố Trạch, tỉnh Quảng Bình của thực dân Pháp

vu AN THAM SAT DAN LANG DANG DE, HUYEN DO TRACH,<br /> TINH QUANG DINH CUA THUC DAN PHAP<br /> <br /> <br /> NGUYIN HUY KHUYEN'<br /> <br /> <br /> <br /> <br /> T rong qua trinh nghidn cQu tdi lidu,<br /> chung t6i da tim dUipc mdt bd hd sd<br /> viet v l vy tham sftt ciia qufin ddi Phftp tai<br /> Iftng hoi H.D.C.C.L.T.T.K (xin giQ nguyen<br /> trong vftn ban) da quy thuan, c6 dat ly<br /> hUdng. D^n Juillet 1949, V.M quftt khdi ly<br /> Iftng D$ng Dd, huy^n BS" Trach, Quang hUdng phai chay v l Quang Khe. Don<br /> Binh. H 6 ad c6 t§n "Vi viic diiu tra vu Quang Khe lft mot don L.H.P d6ng giQ don<br /> thdm sdt ddn ldng Ddng Di • Qudng Khi • trufing lft mot vien thieu uy cua B.T.M mdi<br /> Qudng Binh cua qudn ddi Phdp ndm den.<br /> 1951, sdki hi^u hd sa 1270 phdng luu trd Sau vu tham sftt nfty, mot Ban phu cft'p<br /> Phu Thu Hii'n Trung Viit, ho stJ nay dang c6ng vu da thftnh Iftp mot doftn dilu tra ve<br /> bao quan tai Trung tfim LUu trQ Quoc gia vy vieo nfty. Theo nhU tft'u trinh ciia ong<br /> IV. C6 t h l ndi dfiy lft mpt vi$c lftm dft man Nguyin Toi, 1^ trQcing lftng Dftng Dl, t^ng<br /> ciia Ifnh Phfip dSi vdi nhdn dftn Iftng Dftng Quang Kh§, huyen Bo Trach, tinh Quang<br /> De. Sy viSc duyc mieu ta rft't ky qua bfto Binh cho biet; "nguyen ngfty 23 thftng 8<br /> cao cua 6ng Tinh trUcIng tinh Quang Binh nam 1951, vfto luc 12 gid trUa, mot toan<br /> gQi cho Cy Thu hi^n Trung Vi?t tai Hu^ Knh thuoc dSn Quang Khe, gom 3 ten<br /> nam 1951. Phftp, m6t si" Knh Marocaineo vft Knh thftn<br /> Theo mat tu so 5796ArP/M, ngfty 30 binh Viet Nam da do bo vao lang Dftng De<br /> thftng 8 nftm 1951 cho bi^t: ngfty 22 thang bang hai con dudng, mot mftt bang xuong<br /> may, mot m^t bang dudng bo. Luc d6, bon<br /> 8 nftm 1951, c6 4 ten Knh don Quang KhS<br /> chung gftp trong lang c6 hai nha dang cung<br /> di tudn, den ldng Dftng D l bj du kfch dia<br /> dam chay, nhan dan lai tu hop dong due,<br /> phUdng vay ddnh. Ngay h6m sau 23 thftng<br /> liln bat ho ra xep hftng vft bdn chet rft't<br /> 8 nftm 1951, quan d$i don Quang Khe dgh<br /> nhilu ngQdi, chi con lai mot ong thdy cQng<br /> bat dan lang, giSt chet 154 ngu6i, 6 ngucii<br /> vfi mot ngUdi chii hieu. Sau khi bftn xong<br /> bj thQdng vft bat 30 con bo v l d6n Quang<br /> ngUdi trong hai dam chay do, Knh Phap lai<br /> Khe khign dfin chiing hoang mang sd hai,<br /> bdn chit mdt so ngUdi dang Idp nha, hp<br /> du lufin ra't x6n xao. Lftng Dfing D l lft mot<br /> <br /> <br /> * Khoa Ddng PhUdng - D?i hoc Da L?t<br />  Rghien cini latdi au. ow m.^vn<br /> <br /> cung bj goi xudng xip hftng vft bj bdn. Chua Kit qua m | t si' vfl!^n d l dft duyc n l u nhU<br /> dQng l^i b dd, Knh Phap di vfto Iftng gdp ai sau: Theo td trinh cua fing Tinh trUdng<br /> bdn nft'y, nhft't lft thanh ni§n. Ttfng atf ngUdi Qudng Binh trong tu vftn s i 5796-VP/M<br /> chit lln din gdn 200 ngUdi, bj thUdng trfin ngfiy 30-8-1951, thi hfim 22-8-1951, bin<br /> 20 ngudi. Chiing c6n cUdp di ciia dfin lftng thfin binh d i n Phftp 6 Qudng Khl di tudn<br /> 28 con b6 nQa. t^i lftng Ddng D l bj Vi$t minh phyc kfch,<br /> Vy vi§c nfty l^i tfii diin khi ngfiy 26 thdn binh bj thUdng 1 ngUdi, qua ngfty 23-<br /> thftng 8 nflm 1951, Knh Phdp quay I?i 8-1951 binh Knh din ft'y Ifin vfiy bfit dfin<br /> Ddng D l gilt chit hai ngUdi dfin lftng nQa. lftng D^ng Dl, dem thanh nifin ra bdn chit<br /> 154 ngUdi, 6 ngUdi bj thQdng vft Ifi'y di cua<br /> Theo dng Nguyin Tii thi nguyfin nhfln<br /> dfin 30 con bd.<br /> cua vy tham sftt nfty lft do ngfty 22 thftng 8<br /> nam 1951, vfto khodng 4h chilu c6 mot Theo chilu chi cua Thilu Qy Phdp din<br /> toftn thftn binh Vi^t Nam tudn tilu 5 vQng trudng d i n Quang Khfi thi ngfty 22-8-1951,<br /> nfty, khi di qua D&ng D l bj du kfch dja 4 thftn binh di tudn tilu, IQc trd v l qua dja<br /> phuong chdn danh, cUdp 1 khdu sung, va phdn Ifing Dfing Dl, bj dfin qufin du kfch<br /> lam bj thUdng 1 tfin. Thfin binh dfi bdn chit phyc dftnh, 1 thfin binh bj thudng, hi^n<br /> . 2 vifit minh. dilu trj tai Dong Hdi, qua ngfty 23, ldc 14<br /> gid c6 3 tilu dpi gom c6 thftn binh,<br /> S a u vu vific nfty ngQ6i Phfip d a Iftm gi<br /> Marocains va Phftp dudi sQ chi huy ciia<br /> Theo cong vftn so 53fVPfVCBfM cua Thilu uy don trQdng d i n Dang Dl. Tfin<br /> Phong vien chQc gQi ong Nguyin Vftn Tfch Thilu Qy dQng d ddu lang vdi mot so' binh<br /> v l viec dilu tra vy qudn d^i d i n Quang Knh, con m$t sfi" khfic tiln sfiu vfto lftng, aau<br /> Khe vfiy bftt vft bdn chet dfin Ifing Dflng De dd c6 mpt hIi sung n l , Thilu Qy nfty mdi<br /> d Quang Binh cho hay, da cfi'p cong Ifinh cQ vao trong lang da thfi^y 20 ngQdi bi bdn<br /> mot iiy ban gom c6 ong Nguyin Vfln Tfch chit, 2 ngUdi dftn bft bj thUdng t ^ mot ngoi<br /> vfi V6 Ludng, dai di$n Nha Cfing an Trung nha. Nguyen do dfin d i n v\i vi|c trfin, theo<br /> Vi$t lam hoi vien de ra Quang Binh dilu tfin d i n trudng lft khi d i n ngfii nhft nfty,<br /> tra. tha'y c6 dfing ngQdi, trong s i fiy c6 nhfln<br /> Theo cfing vy l$nh s i 2422VPA^CB c6 d i | n dupe 2 du kfch da tham dy vfto trftn<br /> ghi ro CSLP cong l$nh nfty cho cftc ong: phyc kfch ngfty 22-8-1951.<br /> - Cng Nguyin Vfin Tfch, Tham If Vfin<br /> Theo cfing vfln s i 152B/CM.NH.V cua<br /> phong phu Thu hiln Trung Vi§t lam chu toa.<br /> Ing Trdn Trong Sanh, Gidm die dia<br /> - 6 n g Vd LUdng, dai di§n Nha Cfing an phUdng d Canh sat vfi CIng an QuIc gia tai<br /> Trung Vi$t, hyi vien d l ra cong cdn d Trung Vi$t gQi fing Thu h i l n Trung Vi§t 6<br /> Quang Binh.<br /> H u l cho bilt: Vifin trung ta chi huy binh<br /> CQng theo cfing van sfi'SS da khdng djnh Knh Phfip 6 D i n g Hdi da cQng vifin don<br /> mfit ldn nQa v l vi$c cQ 6ng Vo LUdng, dai trudng d i n Quang K h l v l Ifing Dflng Dl de<br /> dien Nha cfing an Trung Vi$t lftm Hpi vifin phdn phftt cho gia dinh moi nan nhdn bi<br /> d l ra tinh Quang Binh dilu tra vy vi$c hfin chit m | t s^ t i l n Ifi 300$ vfi cfie gia dinh<br /> nfty. bj mfi't bo 1 ta'n gao di chia nhau.<br /> Doan dilu tra da c6 bfio cfio dfti 7 trang Tuy nhiin, sau dd nha chQc trach qufin<br /> gifi'y dftnh may va da trinh l l n cft'p trfin. sy Phfip bdt Ban h^i d i n g vfi Ly truSng<br /> Vu nn ihian stit dim iang...<br /> <br /> Ifing Dflng D l ki gift'y chQng nhftin trong vu Theo td trinh eua ong tinh trUcing tinh<br /> khung bd" d6 chi c6 38 ngudi bj bftn chfi't, vft Quang Binh trong cfing van so 5796-VP/M<br /> vifin trung dy don trudng Quang Khe c6 ngay 30 thftng 8 nflm 1951 cho bilt: hfim<br /> giao lai 15 con ho cho dUdng chu. 22-8-1951, c6 4 thftn binh din Phftp d<br /> Vay la sQ viec trfin da bj bUng bft qua Quang Khfi di tudn tilu tai lftng Dftng Dl<br /> cai cftch mft nha chQc trftch Phftp dft lam la bi ViOt Minh phyc kfch, 1 thftn binh bi<br /> vific phftt gao vft each xQ IJ khfing minh thUdng, ngfty horn sau tQc 23 thang 8 nflm<br /> bach a'y. Cftc con s i trong cac vftn ban 1951, binh Knh don Quang Khe lai den<br /> khong thong nhft't v l si' ngQdi bi gie't va lang Dflng D l dem cdc thanh nien ra bfln<br /> each khdc phuc cung khfing dQde cfing ehet 154 ngQdi, 6 ngQdi bj thQdng va ehung<br /> minh. bat di 30 eon bo.<br /> <br /> Theo eong van so 5796VP ngay 30 thftng Theo ghi ch6p ciia Thieu Qy Phap don<br /> 10-1951 ciia Tinh trudng tinh Quang Binh trUclng din Quang Khe thi ngay 22-8-1951,<br /> 4 than binh di tudn tilu, khi vl den dia<br /> gQi cy Thu hifi'n Trung Vifit tai Hue' thi con<br /> phfin Iftng Dftng De hi quan dftn du kich<br /> s i thanh nien hi gilt lft 154 ngudi, 6 ngudi<br /> phyc danh, 1 than binh bj thUdng va dUdc<br /> bj thUdng, cQng vdi d6 lft la'y di 30 con bd vl<br /> die'u tri tai Dong Hdi. Qua ngay 23 luc 14<br /> don.<br /> gid, c6 3 tieu doi gom thftn binh Marocains<br /> Cong vfln so 1258. CM.NH.V ngfty 29- vft Phap, dudi sU chi huy eua thifi'u uy don<br /> 10-1951 cua giftm do'c dia phUdng canh sat trudng din lang Dang Dl. Tuy nhien vien<br /> vft cong an quo'c gia tai Trung Viet gQi ong thifi'u uy nay khong vao lang ma dQng d<br /> Thu hien 5 Hue'. Trong cfing vftn nfty, cac ngoai lang eung mfit sfi'ten Knh khac, chi eo<br /> nha chQc trach quan sQ Phap bdt Hpi ding mpt top vfto lftng, Sau mfit hoi sung no',<br /> Lf trudng lang Dang De ky gift'y chQng vien thifi'u uy tien vfto trong lang, tha'y eo<br /> nhftn chi co 38 ngUdi bj bfln mft thoi. So bd 20 ngQdi hi hfin chet va 2 ngQ&i dan ba bi<br /> Idy di 30 con ciing chi tra lai 15 con. thQdng. Nguyen do dUdc bie't la Knh Phap<br /> Su vific nfty dupe bilt den ehi khi chung vao lftng thft'y co tu hpp dfing ngUdi, va<br /> toi tim thft'y ho sd vu tham sdt tai Dflng D l chdng nhftn dien dUdc 2 du kieh da chan<br /> qua phfing lUu trQ Phu Thu hiln Trung danh hfim 22-8-1951. Vien thifi'u uy thQa<br /> Viet tai Trung nguyen trung phdn. Qua nhan rdng Knh Phap da lua 25 con bo cua<br /> dfty, chiing tfii xin trich cong bo dfi ban dpc dan lang vl don. Y xac nhftn cuoc hftnh<br /> quan a'y dien ra khoang 20 phdt.<br /> biet den vy tham sat dftm mau eua Knh<br /> Phftp tai miln Trung Viet Nam nftm 1951. Theo ldi khai cua Trung si Bey Net: khi<br /> Theo nhu cfing vii lenh so 2422-VPA^CB y hanh quan cung vdi vien trung uy don<br /> ngfty 9-5-1951 cua Phu Thu hifi'n, LTy ban trUdng, trong khi mfit so linh tien vfio lftng,<br /> difi'u tra gom cae fing Tinh trUdng, Ty roi bong nghe tieng sung no', sau gdn nQa<br /> trucing Cong an tinh Quang Binh, Huyfin tieng y vfto lftng thft'y 20 ngUcJi bj bftn chfi't<br /> trudng huyfin Bo'Trach va cac fing Trung tft va 2 ngUdi hi thQdng.<br /> dai di$n Thilu tUdng uy vien Cong hoa Theo ldi khai eua than hinh Pham Luan,<br /> Trung Viet, Trung tft chi huy quftn sU tinh ehifi'u ngay 22 thang 8 nflm 1951, y eung 2<br /> Quang Binh den t?i ndi xay ra vy tham sftt ten Knh nQa dQdi sU chi huy cua 1 trung si<br /> dilu tra. di tudn tilu, khi qua Iflng Dang Dl each<br />  Tighten ecru Lien sir, su lu.i<br /> <br /> d6n khoang 2km ttft c4 d$u v6 s\f. Tuy Nguyin Tufin (phd h?i trUdng), Nguyin<br /> nhi6n, Wc tr6 vS qua dja phfin ling D?ing Khofii (hUdng kifira), Phan Kifin (hUdng<br /> D^ bi dfin qufin du k(ch ch^n d6nh, 1 thfin kifim) dfiu xfie nhfin nhu ldi khai ciia<br /> binh bj thUdng vft mfi't 1 khSu siing tidu Nguyin T61, chi khfic 14 s6 ngudi bi bfin<br /> li6n thanh, ngolli ra tfi't cS dfiu v6 81^. Qua ch^t Ifi 78-79 ngudi, trong dd cd 2 ngUdi dfin<br /> ngiy 23-8-1951, y l^i tham gia vfio cu^o bfi, alibi thUdng Ifi 11-12 ngudi.<br /> hfinh qufin dlidi si^ chi huy cua vi6n thi^u Cdn nhu thSy tu Phan Uyfin (ngudi da<br /> uy d6n trUcIng. Trong cu^c hfinh qufin nfiy y lfim l l Cling chay) cho bift: y ciing th((y Ifnh<br /> vfio liing syc 9 nhfi bfin chtft 1 thanh nifin Phfip d^n ddng vfi hp lHa thanh men ra b^n<br /> vfi lfim bj thucing 1 ngUdi dfin bfi. Sau cu^c ch^t tai c h i hdn 30 ngudi, t^ng aU ngudi<br /> hfinh qufin, y cho bift bfin chft ca thay 6 trong Ifing bj chft khoang 197 ngudi...<br /> dan qufin, 15 du klch, 2 ngu6i dfin bfi bj<br /> Theo chifo chi ciia Ifing Dfing Dfi hp da<br /> thudng, vfi bfit 25 con bd v6 c?t cl d6n.<br /> thfing kfi dupe danh sfich ciia 80 ngudi chfit<br /> Theo ldi khai cua vifin thfin binh Trfin vft khfim dupe 40 cfii m0 mdi chdn rai rfic<br /> Boi vfi trfin phyc kfch ciia Vi^t Minh trong trong Ifing.<br /> ngfiy 22 cung gifi'ng nhU ldi khai ciia tfin Trfin dfiy 14 nhOng ldi khai cua cic<br /> Pham Lufin. Con rieng vfi ngfiy 23 y cho nhfin chUng, sS li0u mft ngUdi dfin Ifing<br /> bifit: Tifiu dfii cua y di vfiy Ifing Dfing Dfi Dfing Dfi bj gifit dfiu khdng gidng nhau,<br /> • nga d ngofii ruong, chiing phat hi$n ra mpt nhUng nguyfin nhfin thi dfiu xutft phfit tii<br /> nh6ra du klch nen bon chiing da bfin vfio sil tra thil hfin h ? ciia Ifnh Phfip t^i dfin<br /> Udc chiing chfit 5 ngUdi, tuy nhign khi kifim Quang Khfi doi vdi nhQng ngUdi dfin<br /> tra lai chi thfi'y ch^t 2 ngUdi. Sau d6 y cilng thudng vd t^i.<br /> vfio Ifing thfi'y 15 ngiidi hi bfin chfit, 3 ngfiy<br /> D a n lftng D&ng De bi b i n trong<br /> sau y ciing mot s^ binh Ifnh len Ifing de vfiy<br /> bfit L-^f trudng Phan Trac vfi 2 ngUdi thanh t r i i d n g hcrp nfto<br /> nien khfic, nhiing ca 3 ngudi dfi~u bo ch^y, Theo nhu tfii li$u vft nhQng ldi khai ciia<br /> cho nen y da bfin ch^t ca 3 ngUdi. cfie nhfin chdng cung nhU tfii li§u lUu trQ<br /> d l l»i, thi sd di dfin l i n g Dfing Dfi bi linh<br /> Theo ldi khai ciia tfin 1^ triidng Ifing<br /> Phfip don Quang Khe tham sfit ngfiy 23<br /> Dfing D l Ifi ong Nguyin Toi thl vfio liic 12<br /> thfing 8 nfim 1961 Ifi vi ngfiy 22-8-1951, c6<br /> gid trUa ngfiy 23-8-1951, c6 mOt tofin linh<br /> 4 thfin binh cua Phfip di tufin tilu, khi di<br /> dong thudc don Quang Khfi gom c6 3 tfin<br /> qua dja phfin Ifing Dfing Dfi bj Vi$t Minh<br /> Phfip, Marocains vfi thfin binh d^ hfy vfio<br /> phyc kfch dfin d i n 1 thfin binh bi thUdng.<br /> Ifing, nhan gfip c6 nhfi lfim dfim chay, ngudi<br /> dfin tu tfip dong diic, Unh Phfip lifin bfit hp Cfie vfin ban ag 6796AT; cdng vfin so<br /> xfip hfing bfin chfit rft't nhifiu ngiidi. Sau d6 163VPWCBM; ca vftn ban k i t qua cuoc<br /> chiing lai di Ifing cfie nhfi trong Ifing g$p ai difiu tra vy dfin Ifing Dfing Dfi bj b? ddi dfin<br /> bfin nfi'y, nhfi't Ifi thanh nien, tong stf ngiidi Quang Khfi bfin c h i t vfi bi thUdng ngfiy 23-<br /> Udc khoang 194 ngiidi vfi 20 ngiidi b; 8-1961... dfi'u thCfng nhft't vdi f k i l n trfin.<br /> thiidng, Knh Phfip l^i lHa di ciia dfin lftng D a n lftng S | i n g D l b) b&n vdi ly do<br /> 28 con bo. gi<br /> Vfi phfin ldi khai ciia ban L^ hiidng lftng hi do mfi dfin l i n g Dfing Dfi bi chit oan<br /> Dfing Dfi Ifi Phan PhUdng (hdi trudng), trong ngfiy 23 thfing 8 nftm 1951 Ifi vi, khi<br /> Vu to HiAm s6t dto lAng..<br /> <br /> <br /> Bdng I: Bdng so sftnh nhuFng IQi khai cue m^t s£^ ngUdi<br /> Loli k h a i c u a cfie n h a n chlVng 88 n g u d i bi So n g u ^ i b] Sd'bdbibStvS<br /> ch£t thiiolng dfin<br /> Tinh trucInK QuanR Binh 154 6 30 con<br /> Don trudng dfin Quani: Khfi 20 3 25<br /> TrunE o! BEY NET 20 2<br /> Th&n binh P h a m - Luan 21 2 25<br /> Than binh Tran - Boi 23<br /> Lv truSnE ISnE DSnE D l Neuven - Toi 194 20 28<br /> Ly hUdnE ISnE DfinE D l P h a n - PhuonR 78-79 2<br /> <br /> Bftng 2: Danh sftch tSn nhQng ngUdi bj mfi't do d^c vft tiSn bac<br /> <br /> Stt T S n vft hg Tuli T i ^ n b a c vk d o bi m a t<br /> 1 Npuv^n D6c 22 1.600,000 bgc Don^DifOng<br /> 2 P h a n CW 22 M6t c&i sfip bi ph& huy, trj RI& 120,000<br /> 3 Npuyin Du3nK 45 Mfit con heo v i mfit cfii chum tri gik 450,000<br /> 4 N R 6 MUC 66 3 dfii v6ng b a c 2 cfii chum, 1 c6i vai tri sik 200,00<br /> 5 P h a n T Chiu 32 1 con heo, 1 con trfiu bi biln ch§'t tri gi& 1.500<br /> 6 Ng6Li§n 44 Hai c6i nha bj dfi't tri gifi 3.000,00 vk 7.000,00 b^c Dong<br /> DUdne bi mfi't<br /> 7 Nffuvln Thi Thdi 35 1.7000.00 bac Dfing DUdng bi mfl't<br /> 8 P h a n T N§y 25 100,00 b^c Dfing DUdng bj mfi't, 1 cai chum vfi 1 dfii vong<br /> tav b i n e bac bi be tri gifi 100.00<br /> g Cao T Dien 1 cfii vai vfi 2 dfii vong tay bi mfi't, tri gifi 90,00<br /> 10 Nffuyen T Thf 1 cfii mfin bi mfi't tri gifi 100,00<br /> 11 P h a n T Em 2 dfii vong tay, 1 cfii chum vfi ch6n dpi bj b l nat trj gia<br /> 150,00<br /> 12 Nguyen Xinh ChfSn doi bi hi tri eifi 200.00<br /> 13 Nguyin T Chau 300,00 bac Dfitig Dudng bi mfi't<br /> 14 1 doi vong bi mfi't tri gifi 400,00'<br /> 15 P h a n T Van 27 1 cfii kieng bac, 1 bfi fio qufin den, 1 cfii binh, 4 cii ly, 10<br /> dfii dUa mun, 1 cfii bfit ufi'ng nUfic xUa, t n gifi 500,00<br /> <br /> <br /> qufin Phap ti^n vSo l^ng thi gfip iii6t dam Tmh truSng Ifi g i n 154 ngUcIi, h^u day c6<br /> d6ng tai mot gia dinh, trong dam dong S'y phai Ifi con sS" chinh xac khong? Trong tfi't<br /> chiing phat hi§n c6 hai du kich da chan ca cac Icii khai cua cac nhfin chUng deu<br /> danh chiing hom 22 thang 8 niim 1951, vk khac nhau ve con s6 bi gi^t. Vfiy, c6 bao<br /> chiing da diing siing b^n x6i xa vko dam nhieu ngu6i dan Ifing hi gig^t? Cau hoi nfiy<br /> dong nky. Sau do, chiing con tig'n t h i n g vko hien nay chiing toi ciing kh5ng t h l dieu tra<br /> Ikng gkp ai b^n nSy, da phin Ik thanh trilc tig'p t^i dia phUOng. NhUng hMdc d^u<br /> nign, dfin d^n mot cuoc tham sat d§m mau c6 th^ kh4ng dinh c6 khoang 80 ngUcfi hi<br /> tai Dang De. gi^t Ifi digV chfic chfin.<br /> Dan l a n g D ^ n g D^ b i b a n c h e t v a bi Qua bang 1, ciing nhU so sfinh doi chieu<br /> thiftfng b a o n h i e u ngiJcfi v6i bang ke cac nan nhfin bi bfin chet, con so<br /> hdu nhu khong fin khdp, tuy vfiy, vu vigc nfiy<br /> Theo nhu ban di^u tra da khfim x6t<br /> Ifi c6 th^t vfi s^ngUcii chet c6 th^ Ifi hdn nfla.<br /> trong Ifing phfit h i | n hdn 40 ng6i ma m6i,<br /> k§ danh sach nhflng ngUcfi hi giet 80 ngUcti. Ngofii vi$c giet nguSi, hnh Phap da cU6p<br /> Nhu vfiy, theo nhU tUclng trinh cua 6ng di m6t so vfit dung do dac cua mot s6'ngUSi<br />  Hghlfin ellru Ljch aJr. atf 10.2018<br /> <br /> <br /> B&nR 3: Dnnh sfich nhdrng n^n nhfin dfi bl ch^t ta Ifine Dfine Bi<br /> SU H^ Un ngutrt TudI Tfin cha, ICn m ; C6 chdtiR hay v i ; Mtfy con Blchd<br /> chA<br /> 1 Hum TWc {y 47 Cha m^ che'l v.? Ngu Thi Phiic 5 c on, 4 tnil, 1 gdi Ng - T - Phdc<br /> <br /> 2 PUanSa IK ITian Trfc V Q NKA Thi Khuvfn 0 NgO-T-Phfic<br /> 3 HianBttn 17 Phan Tuy^n V